Nonviolence and Communication
نویسندگان
چکیده
Communication is central to the effectiveness of nonviolent action: methods of protest and persuasion are essentially means of communication, while methods of noncooperation and nonviolent intervention have crucial communicative dimensions. As a mode of political communication, nonviolence can be contrasted with rational dialogue, electoral politics and violence, and stands out from them in combining high transformative potential with dialogue and participation. The more well studied dimensions of nonviolence as communication are dialogue with opponents, power equalization to prepare for dialogue, and mobilization of third parties. To these should be added two further dimensions, collective and individual empowerment. Two cases of nonviolent resistance in the Soviet Union the 1991 coup and the 1953 prison camp strikes at Norilsk and Vorkuta are used to illustrate the dimensions of nonviolence as communication in practice. These examples reveal the importance of communication in nonviolent action. They also suggest the difficulty in gaining information on empowerment, especially individual empowerment, which may be one reason why these dimensions have been neglected. The five-dimension framework of nonviolence as communication has the limitation that many actions mix two or more dimensions. Examining the communicative dimensions of nonviolence can alert both activists and researchers to the fact that nonviolent actions do not 'speak for themselves'.
منابع مشابه
How Nonviolence is Misrepresented
PETER GELDERLOOS IN his book How Nonviolence Protects the State claims that nonviolence is ineffective, racist, statist, patriarchal, tactically and strategically inferior, and deluded.1 His attack on nonviolence is fierce and unrelenting. To assess Gelderloos’ views, I first outline the case for nonviolence and the associated case against violence. This provides a foundation for examining Geld...
متن کاملPersistency and Nonviolence Decision Problems in P/T-Nets with Step Semantics
Persistency is one of the notions widely investigated due to its application in concurrent systems. The classical notion refers to nets with a standard sequential semantics. We will present two approaches to the issue (nonviolence and persistency). The classes of different types of nonviolence and persistency will be defined for nets with step semantics. We will prove that decision problem conc...
متن کاملBarnett Newman , Gandhi , and the Aesthetics of Nonviolence
Taking the painting Be I by famous American Abstract Expressionist painter Barnett Newman as a starting point, this paper explores relationships between Mohandas K. Gandhi’s aesthetic life and an emerging aesthetic of nonviolence in the post WWII era. A nonviolent aesthetic is considered in the painting and in relation to two key photographs featured in the exhibition “Experiments with Truth: G...
متن کاملOn Persistent Reachability in Petri Nets
The notion of persistency, based on the rule “no action can disable another one” is one of the classical notions in concurrency theory. In this paper, we deal with arbitrary place/transition nets, but concentrate on their persistent computations. It leads to an interesting decision problem: Is a given marking reachable with a persistent run? In order to study the persistent-reachability problem...
متن کامل